Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Mainland China and Taiwan were one country. It is bizarre to try to deny it.

Taiwan was part of China and ceded to Japan by treaty after the first Sino-Japanese war of 1895. It was then "reunited" to China following WWII... that's really the root of the current situation since that's why the Chinese government (ROC) retreated there in 1949. Taiwan held the Chinese seat at the UN until the 1970s!

Hongkong was also seized by the UK through naked imperialistic aggression and it is testament to the power of propaganda that China be painted as "the bad guys".

Your comment is not factually correct irrespective of rights and wrongs or wishes of the people in Taiwan.

Why should people always have an ulterior motive beyond stating things as they are?...



> Your comment is not factually correct irrespective of rights and wrongs or wishes of the people in Taiwan.

Unless you are one of those I don't think you get to speak for them.


When did I speak for them or anyone?

No need to discuss further if that's going to turn into this. People really need to take a step back and a deep breath when discussing world issues.

I am not even Chinese or Asian if that is your suggestion (a little in the gutter, by the way). I don't have skin in the game and am just looking at history in the most factual way I can.


> No need to discuss further if that's going to turn into this.

Into what? A discussion where one party berates another for not appreciating the 'wishes of the people in Taiwan'?

You can't credibly make that claim without being transparent about your own nationality.


He said he was looking at history and present reality in the most factual way. Perhaps for you, your identity shapes your viewpoint more than the facts do. Why don't you provide your arguments instead of questioning his nationality?


A properly aged account that suddenly springs to life without ever before having commented on anything or submitted a single link. What a joyful occasion.


I usually prefer reading perspectives over expressing my own, but your bias and ill intentions have compelled me to speak up.


Sure...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: