Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Related analysis of open data:

"The NYPD Was Systematically Ticketing Legally Parked Cars for Millions of Dollars a Year- Open Data Just Put an End to It"

https://iquantny.tumblr.com/post/144197004989/the-nypd-was-s...



Love it when a bunch of people get paid by the state to put on matching uniforms, go out into the streets strapped with guns & handcuffs and straight up extort millions of dollars from everyday citizens for legally parking (with virtual immunity from prosecution).


Not to mention "while exempting themselves and their friends from repercussions for parking illegally".


There's a bus stop in front of my local police station. Or there would be, if the police weren't always parked in it.

https://i.imgur.com/wtKE33h.png

$50 ticket if I did that.


There's a police station in Harlem where the police regularly angle park across the bike lane, where the street pattern: [ traffic lane | bike lane | parallel parking lane]). I have seen police officers there ticketing riders for not riding in the bicycle lane WHILE THAT LANE WAS BLOCKED BY POLICE CARS.


I wish the technology existed so they could just correctly bill you when you get back to your car and you drive away with a receipt instead of a fine... the idea that you have done something wrong and you deserve a financial punishment for it is ludicrous.


In much of NYC, parking is free and it's cheaper to eat the ticket for skipping alternate-side parking than it is to long-term park your car in the closest lot.


This is in the same vein as the trial services that start billing you if you forget to cancel. I'd like to see the model for parking but I bet it turns out it contributes a lot to the bottom line so they don't want to change it.


Copenhagen (among other places) has a pretty convenient app-based model for parking. You use one of a few competing apps on your phone and enter your car's registration plate. When you park you open the app and it pulls location and starts a timer. You pick an amount of time you'll be parked but the apps I've used have reminders and you can trivially extend parking as you feel appropriate.

When you get back in your car you open the app and 'stop parking' and the app calculates the cost of the time you were parked (taking into account varying overnight and congestion zone rates). At the end of the month you get billed for that month's charges. You can also have multiple personas if you have a work vehicle/card.

In parts of south Florida there's a somewhat similar system where there's only one app you can use and money is taken immediately for the duration of the time you choose (with a small service fee included, of course). If you move your car before the expiration of your purchased time, you lose that value unless you repark in the same area [1]. The similarity is that the app will remind you that your parking is going to expire soon and you can simply extend (and pay that small service fee again, of course). I've seen this prepay-via-app model at various private parking facilities in other US cities as well.

[1]: The system uses number codes for what area you're parked in so you don't need to have location services necessarily (e.g. parking garage) with the code changing every couple streets.


Parking enforcement generally doesn't have guns & handcuffs, in my experience.


They do when you want to make a point more than you want to be truthful. I mean, truth...who cares, right?


Some jurisdictions here exclusively use non-armed officers to issue parking tickets but rest just use the cops.

Try arguing with the issuing officer over the unlawful ticket or skipping the fine/court appearance and see which type of officers they send to enforce it.


And the partner post

"Success: How NYC Open Data and Reddit Saved New Yorkers Over $55,000 a Year"

https://iquantny.tumblr.com/post/87573867759/success-how-nyc...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: