A more cynical interpretation is that he almost certainly tried to sell this to MS privately, and they didn't bite at the price he was asking. The public offering at $1.7M is likely an attempt to force their hand.
Frankly that doesn't sound to expensive given the context, it's probably less than Microsoft's existing bug bounty budget anyway. I don't know why they couldn't work this out, or why they never bothered to try to address the issue over the multiple decades this guy has been keeping this domain out of dangerous hands.
With a large organization like Microsoft, people who understand this don’t have the power to make this happen. And people who the power will WTF this for 6 months. By the time they make the decision, it will be too late. I doubt Satya will read this.
It took me half hour to understand what is going on. Imagine an MS executive
They’ve just changed default settings to neuter the issue, and hoped the problem with established networks would eventually go away on its own as people upgraded.
In fact, I bet that domain was much more valuable in 2005 than it is now.
It is. "adventus.com" just sold for 22k. "mymind.com" sold for 36k. "rude.com" sold for 100k. "gorilla.com" sold for almost 500k and "voice.com" sold for 30 million!
Any offer below 500k would be downright ridiculous.
Because it's fundamentally Microsofts mistake? The asking price for the domain isn't unreasonable given it's a 4 letter .com and Microsoft can easily afford it.
Frankly that doesn't sound to expensive given the context, it's probably less than Microsoft's existing bug bounty budget anyway. I don't know why they couldn't work this out, or why they never bothered to try to address the issue over the multiple decades this guy has been keeping this domain out of dangerous hands.
Just write the check, Satya.